Legal Elite of the Upstate

A Veteran-Owned Business

'Top 40 Under 40' award by The National Trial Lawyers

Seal of the Million Dollar Advocates Forum


Call Us For Free Consultation



What Is Comparative Negligence In South Carolina?

The Carolina Law Group > Blog  > What Is Comparative Negligence In South Carolina?

What Is Comparative Negligence In South Carolina?

Matt Whitehead | Attorney, The Carolina Law Group

Matt Whitehead | Attorney, The Carolina Law Group

What Is Comparative Negligence In South Carolina?

Let’s say you were in a car accident with a driver in another vehicle. Both of you have suffered injuries and have sustained damage to your cars. Both of you are looking at big expenses.

And both of you were partially responsible for the accident.

What happens now? Who can recover damages? Who’s on the hook for paying those damages?

What Happens When More Than One Person Is at Fault?

Different states figure out the answers to these questions differently. A few states follow a rule of “contributory negligence.” Many others, including South Carolina, follow the rule of “comparative negligence.”

What’s the difference?

In short, with contributory negligence, a driver generally cannot recover damages at all if he or she is responsible for causing any part of the accident. To put it another way, in most cases of ordinary negligence the only parties who can recover damages are those who are 0% responsible for the accident.

Instead, with comparative negligence, a driver who is partially at fault for the accident can recover damages, as long as their negligence was the same or less in comparison to the other driver(s). However, the amount of damages they are able to recover is reduced according to how negligent they were. To put it another way, the more liable a driver is for causing the accident, the less they can recover.

Who Recovers What?

Another important factor in accidents with more than one negligent driver is apportionment. That is, exactly how negligent each party was, by percentage. If one driver sues another and the matter goes to court, the jury may be instructed to determine how responsible each driver was. They may find, for example, that Driver 1 was 65% negligent while Driver 2 was only 35% negligent.

In a contributory negligence state, neither Driver 1 nor Driver 2 would be eligible to recover damages in most cases, as they both contributed to the accident.

In a comparative negligence state, such as South Carolina, Driver 2 would be able to recover a portion of the total damages, but Driver 1 would be barred from recovery. In our example, because Driver 2 was 35% responsible, Driver 2 would be able to recover 65% of his or damages.

What Happens When Fault is 50-50?

There are different kinds of comparative negligence, and South Carolina follows a “modified comparative negligence” rule that allows someone to recover damages if they are up to 50% negligent. It’s possible that if Driver 1 sued Driver 2, and both were found to be exactly 50% negligent, Driver 1 would be able to recover 50% of his or her total damages.

When to Work with a Car Accident Attorney

Don’t assume that if an accident was partially your fault, you’re automatically barred from recovering damages.

If you were involved in a car accident in South Carolina that resulted in personal injury or significant property damage, you should work with an experienced lawyer – especially if you believe you were partially responsible for the accident. Your lawyer can work with you to help you recover the damages you’re entitled to. Get in touch with one of the personal injury attorneys at The Carolina Law Group today. Fill out our contact form or call one of the numbers below to schedule your free initial consultation.

The Carolina Law Group has four offices in upstate South Carolina for your convenience: Greenville (principal office; call 864.312.4444), West Greenville (864.312.4444), Greer (principal office; call 864.757.5555), and Spartanburg (principal office; call 864.757.5555). Call today.


Matt is a graduate of the South Carolina’s Honors College and the Darla Moore School of Business at the University of South Carolina where he obtained an undergraduate degree in Business Administration. Matt later obtained a Juris Doctor degree from the University of South Carolina School of Law where was a member of the South Carolina Law Review and the legal fraternity Phi Alpha Delta. Matt’s education and experience provides valuable insight into how insurance companies approach the litigation process. This allows Matt to closely work with his clients in protecting their legal rights from the initial claim stage through trial.

Translate »